Where I tend to part ways is on how one defines those values.  Many conservatives have a very very short list of what seems to matter to them: abortion, homosexuality, public religious symbols, etc.

In the last election cycle I received a voters guide in the bulletin of a conservative church I was attending and it made absolutely no mention of core Christian values like justice, helping the poor, peacemaking, etc.

Even though these are direct commandments of Jesus!

And, of course, all the “Jesus approved” candidates were Republicans.